Consignment Shop vs. Thrift Store: What Are The Differences?

a woman on a chair with shopping bags next to her

Buying pre-loved products is an excellent alternative to the traditional retail experience, promoting a sustainable approach to consumerism. The secondhand market has experienced immense growth in recent years.

Factors contributing to these are growing awareness of environmental issues, supply chain problems, and consumer behavior.

Consignment shops and thrift stores are two business models in secondhand shopping. While both offer pre-loved goods, the business model differs in shopping experience, pricing, and ownership.

This article explores the differences between consignment stores vs thrift stores so business owners can make informed decisions that align with their strategy.

Table of Contents:

Consignment Shops: An Overview

a woman shopping at a consignment store

The consignment shops feature a specific business model where the consignor leaves their items and gets a part of the revenue after the sale. For business owners wishing to profit, it is a great option.

The consignment shop has minimal financial risk since the products aren't in their possession. The goods can be returned to their owner if they don't sell.

Definition and Business Model

A consignment shop is an establishment that sells items on behalf of individuals and businesses, also called consignors. The business model makes it easy for individuals to sell unwanted items without spending time on direct sales.

The consignment shop earns revenue by charging a commission as a percentage of the retail price. The commission rate varies, but in most cases, it is 40% of the price. This means the consignor takes 60% of the price after the sales.

The consignor is the one that keeps the ownership of the products and not the store. In some arrangements, a period of consignment can be implemented.

This means that if the goods are sold within a specific time, they will be returned to the owner. This period can be extended upon mutual agreement.

Quality and Selection

Consignment stores are committed to providing quality products with a strict selection process. The products should pass evaluation before being placed on the shelves.

The expert staff will inspect the items and make sure only high-quality and well-maintained items are displayed for sale. Consignment shops pay close attention to curating their inventory and accepting products that potentially appeal to their target customers.

The goal is to make the shopping experience more refined for the customers. Also, the selection process helps shape higher pricing.

Also Read: How to Authenticate Designer Clothes

Thrift Stores: An Overview

a person holding a red dress shirt

A thrift store relies on individual donations, such as clothing, decor, books, furniture, etc. The product category, condition, or brand determines the price.

Definition and Purpose

A thrift store is a retail establishment that sells donated and secondhand items at a low price. The concept does not include compensation for the individuals who donate their goods.

The thrift store relies on the generosity of the individuals who want to donate items. This is one of the main differences between thrift and consignment. The goal is to provide affordable products that cater to a wide range of customers.

While the sole purpose of a consignment shop is profit, thrift shops support charitable causes. The business model functions as a charitable organization that covers the operational costs and dedicates the revenue to charity.

Variety and Pricing

Thrift stores offer a wide range of products while keeping the prices affordable. Customers can find furniture, clothing, electronics, books, and decor.

The thrift store pricing is lower than traditional retail stores, attracting customers with limited budgets. The product price is set based on its condition. Since the items are donated, and there is no obligation for compensation, thrift stores achieve lower costs than consignment stores.

The Consignment Experience

The consignment business model provides a mutually beneficial arrangement between consignment stores and consignors. Individuals who want to declutter and make some money will hand their goods to the store, which is responsible for displaying and selling the products.

The arrangement is beneficial for the consignor and the store. It is a hassle-free way for individuals to sell their goods. In addition, it is a great way for stores to source high-quality and unique items.

Interactions with Consignors

The consignment business model includes collaboration between the store and consignors. The consignor's goods are carefully inspected to ensure they meet the quality standards and appeal to the target audience.

When the items are accepted, they remain in the consignor's ownership. The consignment store must establish excellent communication with the consignors for a streamlined process.

The consignment store should provide transparent guidelines on the acceptable items, payout, and pricing. Updating the consignor about the sales and inventory helps build a great professional relationship.

Customer Experience

The consignment store provides a distinctive shopping experience for the customers looking for quality and uniqueness. It features a mix of treasure hunting, excellent quality, affordable prices, and sustainability, a great alternative to mainstream shopping.

For customers, entering a consignment store resembles a treasure hunt. The atmosphere of anticipation and unique finds shape the shopping experience.

The consignment store inventory is constantly changing, which adds the element of surprise to the experience. Customers will feel excitement when entering the store, encouraging repetitive visits to find what they're looking for.

Consignment stores inspect the goods before they hit the shelves, so customers can only find well-maintained items. This contributes to a streamlined shopping experience and debunks the myth that buying pre-loved goods means compromised quality.

The Thrift Store Experience

Despite the possibility of finding items for a very low price, customers love thrift stores for their other benefits. Thrift stores offer unique finds, perfect for those looking for distinct styles from mass production. But also, buying pre-owned items reduces waste and contributes to sustainability.

The thrift store experience revolves around creating a treasure hunt atmosphere for customers looking for unique finds. Whether they are after a pair of designer jeans or vintage decor, customers will check the thrift store for different needs.

Community Engagement

Thrift stores positively impact the community and are more than just retail establishments. Despite offering affordable products, their direct contribution to local communities is vital.

Thrift stores establish close relationships with charities and donate a significant portion of their sales to support different causes. They also involve the community by offering volunteering opportunities.

Through these initiatives, the thrift stores become community hubs for engagement, promoting sustainable practices, and positively impacting society.

Unpredictability in Thrift Store Finds

Mainstream retail stores have a consistent inventory that follows the same pattern. The allure of thrift stores lies in their unpredictability, adding the element of surprise to the shopping experience.

Shoppers don't know which hidden treasures await on the shelves, creating a feeling of anticipation. The thrift shop experience is unique, as no two carry the same inventory.

The unpredictability is what attracts the treasure hunters and shifting enthusiasts. Finding the same item in two thrift stores is almost impossible, even if they are the same brand.

Therefore, shoppers don't go to their nearest thrift store with a shopping list. They indulge in the immersive experience of finding the unexpected, so the concept revolves around impulsive purchases.

The concept of scarcity creates a sense of rush. The changing nature of the inventory means that once an item is sold, it might never be restocked. The scarcity transforms the objects into rare finds, stimulating the urge to buy.

Thrift vs. Consignment Stores Pricing

white T-shirt hanging on a counter

One of the critical differences in the thrift vs consignment stores is the pricing model. While both offer products for an affordable price, thrift stores tend to be on the cheaper side when we compare them.

As mentioned, the consignment stores feature a curated selection of products tailored to their target audience. This will reflect the prices, making them higher than thrift stores.

On the other hand, thrift stores have a different approach to defining the prices. They rely on a low-price strategy and usually have a flat rate system, where each product category has a fixed price.

The condition of the product also plays a crucial role in pricing. Items that are in pristine condition will have a higher price tag than the ones that are used.

When analyzing consignment shops vs. thrift store pricing, consignment shops feature a curated selection. On the other hand, thrift stores provide affordable options.

Thrift stores offer goods of varying quality, and the price reflects that. Shoppers who don't mind getting their hands on a DIY project can get economically priced items and fix them.

As we mentioned earlier, a consignment shop focuses only on high-quality items. Shoppers don't need to analyze the condition of the products since the staff already did this. Most consignment stores will also authenticate designer clothes before listing them for sale.


When analyzing consignment vs thrift as business models, we can spot the similarities. Both give a second life to used items and provide goods at an affordable price.

The sustainability aspect of thrift and consignment focuses on reducing waste. The customers can find rare and vintage items that reflect their style and speak for their soul.

The shopping experience is similar for both business models. Customers love the joy of discovery that the treasure-hunting process provides.

Also, both business models promote sustainable practices. They stimulate the reuse of items that would otherwise end up in landfills.

However, there are a few significant differences. Consignment stores undergo a strict selection process to provide high-quality goods. On the other hand, the selection process in a thrift store includes visibly used items and assigns them a suitable price.

The ownership is another prominent difference between thrift and consignment. The consignor retains ownership over the items until they are sold, whereas the donor doesn't. The thrift store owns the articles, and they are not obligated to provide financial compensation. 

Related Posts

Translation missing: en.general.cookie_form.cookie_text Translation missing: en.general.cookie_form.read_more